It was interesting to hear Jonathan Harris speak about his ideas and work, as well as play around with his websites, “
We Feel Fine” and “
Universe”.
Personally, I found “We Feel Fine” to be more intriguing. It's pretty ambitious to attempt to gather and track human emotions based on blog postings. Human emotions are one of those grey areas where it seems to be very difficult to organize and quantify them by computer logic.
All in all, it's a good effort; albeit with some gaps. One of the issues is linguistic. By searching for “I feel”, you get not only emotions, but also people who feel something physically and those who use that phrase in place of “I think”. It also siphons out a certain flavor of emotion, but perhaps not the direct experience – you would get “I feel loved” but not “I love.”
Another thing to be aware of is demographics. Blogs are primarily used by teenagers and people in their twenties, so you're just getting a slice of emotion from a certain life stages when you search through the default view. People in later stages of life should have some different insights and feelings based on their experiences, and I appreciate that the website does allow you to filter based on age (along with many other criteria).
Design-wise, I thought it was quite pleasing to the eye and liked having multiple ways to view data. While, the random picking of the “Murmurs” view was interesting, it ended up being weighted towards picking larger circles (easier to select) and brighter colors (jumps out of the screen more). I did have some computer processing issues when using the website, so I tended to stay away from “Montages” and selecting quotes with pictures. I spent some time with the “Mounds” view to see the range of emotions that were being collected. Of course, what does it say about me by the terms I selected to look at?
What I like about the site is the opportunity to stumble onto a random bit of poetry that speaks to being human:
“i love the sound of rain pattering softly on your window as you lay back in your bed the fuzzy feeling you get when the person you like looks into your eyes and the pure bliss of remembering the things that have passed.”
“i feel drawn to the evil chanting hordes they seem to mesmerize me”
-
“i can see how you are beautiful can you feel my eyes on you i'm shy and turn my head away working late in diner citylight I see that you get home alright make sure that you can't see me hoping you will see me.”
Perhaps it's a bit voyeuristic, but it's a chance to see the world through someone else's eyes for a moment.
Which I guess ties into the notion of privacy, which seems to be getting more and more outdated by the moment. Yes, they people are posting to a blog and putting their thoughts out publicly, but I would imagine most think that their blog might by read by friends or perhaps friends of friends through some normal social network logic. Would they think that some stranger might read their words purely based on how they say they feel? If so, do you think it would it change what they write? For most people, I imagine probably not; in general, we have a self-centered, celebrity-driven culture. Any attention is good attention. But for others, it may make you think twice about what you post online. Perhaps in the future, those who post that they feel depressed will receive comments back advertising Prozac.
Overall, I think the “Universe” concept is a lot less interesting. There are already so many places where you can get and gather news information that I don't think the site has as much impact. The “Universe” is tied to the here and now of public events. Although information is grouped, sorted, and linked in the site, I don't think really captures the the overarching themes of our stories and “mythologies”. News postings tend not to be very poetic and there is suggesting of modern archetypes (for example, hypocritical politician, devastating weather event, “news” with product tie-in, feel-good fluff, etc.). I get the sense that Jonathan Harris had the basic programming structure built from “We Feel Fine” and was curious to apply it to another venue. This is like the exterior face that we show the world, whereas “We Feel Fine” exposes more of the interior thoughts and processes.
In Jonathan's comments, I did appreciate the emphasis on making work that is meaningful to its creator. I was wondering what felt wrong with my last class exercise; I realized that normally I wouldn't do social commentary and it wasn't sitting so well internally. While the work itself may be valid, I felt like I was picking on easy targets and saying things that had already been said (and probably in wittier fashion). Whereas I really like the previous in-class composition of day & night juxtaposition, probably because it dealt with more universal concepts that the viewer could consider. Oh well, on some days the right ideas come to you – other days not so much.