Reading through the assigned reading about critiques, I noticed that there seems to be a bit of a difference between group critiques in the design world vs. the art world.
Within the design world, there is an objective or assignment from someone external that must be fulfilled in order to be successful. The design could be the most unique and beautiful thing in the world, but if it doesn't communicate the necessary information then essentially it fails. Ultimately, design is practical.
Whereas with art, although there may be an assignment (in the context of school) or a commission, ultimately the artist's vision and implementation are the key elements in determining success. Communication of the artist's ideas may be important, but every viewer may bring a different interpretation to the piece which would inform their critique and ultimately their judgment of the piece's success.
Going through the articles, it also brought to mind and motivated me to re-read "The Crit" chapter in Sarah Thornton's Seven Days in the Art World. In it she describes sitting in on CalArt's Post-Studio Art critique for graduate students which on that day lasted from 10 am to about 1 am the next morning.... just to discuss the work of three students. It sounds like the process of breaking people down in order to rebuild in part of the artistic development process there. Happily I don't expect our critique to take quite that amount of time. Sarah also ties in discussions that she's had with other academics about the pros and cons of group critiques and how they may work. On of the most interesting critiques of group critiques ties into having to use words to describe something should be able to communicate visually, particularly in instances where the the artist is supposed to present their own work.
I'm actually looking forward to the group critique this week. I've been so buried in my own little world working on the final project that I think it'll be helpful to hear feedback from people who are seeing it fresh. Hopefully this will give me a better idea about what is working, what is in need of improvement, and possibly even ideas on how to deal with some technical issues not yet resolved.
No comments:
Post a Comment